Anno Domini MMXXVI · A Bill of Fare

A Thanksgiving Feast, After the Manner of 1650

Thursday, November 26, 2026

This year we're eating like the Plymouth colonists and their Wampanoag neighbors would have — fowl, pork, shellfish, corn, squash, roots, and cider. The host is making the meats, stews & fish, breads, and cider. The sides and sweets need cooks.

  1. RSVP once for your whole family so the recipes are sized for the crowd.
  2. Pick a side or sweet, read its recipe, and claim it.
  3. Follow the recipe as written. Everything is at Publix or Walmart here in SWFL.

Who's Coming?

One RSVP per family, by Sunday, Nov 22. Shopping lists are final on Monday, Nov 23.

0 families
0 adults
0 kids

No families yet — be the first!

0 of 8 dishes spoken for

The Great Meats

Roast Turkey

The great fowl of the feast, roasted plain with butter, salt, and herbs.

The Host

Governor Bradford wrote that the colonists had “great store of wild turkeys” that autumn. Fowl was the centerpiece of the 1621 harvest feast.

Hardwood-Smoked Pork Ribs

Low and slow over hardwood smoke.

The Host

Colonists kept hogs from the earliest years, and the Wampanoag smoked meat and fish over wood fires to preserve it. Smoke + swine = fair game.

Pottages & Fish

Sobaheg (Wampanoag Turkey, Corn & Bean Stew)

A thick, hearty stew of hominy, beans, squash, and fowl — the Wampanoag everyday dish.

The Host

Sobaheg is a Wampanoag stew made from whatever the season offered: dried corn, beans, squash, meat or fish, thickened with ground nuts or sunflower seeds.

Makes 12 servingsHands-on 45 minTotal 3 hrs (or make the day before)

Stewed Mussels with Herbs & Butter

Shellfish steamed in cider and butter with onion and parsley.

The Host

Edward Winslow's 1621 letter boasts the colonists could gather mussels, clams, and lobsters with ease. Shellfish was everyday food.

Makes 12 servingsHands-on 25 minTotal 30 min — cook right before eating

Baked Cod with Butter & Herbs

Plain white fish baked under a blanket of butter, onion, and parsley.

The Host

Cod built New England — it's why Cape Cod has its name. Fish was served at nearly every meal.

Makes 12 servingsHands-on 20 minTotal 45 min

Sides from the Garden

Stewed Pompion (Pumpkin)

Pumpkin cooked down with butter, vinegar, and ginger. Sweet, sour, and savory.

Needs a cook

John Josselyn wrote in 1672 that this was “an ancient New England standing dish” — pumpkin stewed with butter, a little vinegar, and spice, “to make it tart like an apple.”

Makes 12 servingsHands-on 30 minTotal 1½ hrs

Roasted Roots in Drippings

Turnips, parsnips, carrots, and onions roasted until caramelized.

Needs a cook

The English brought turnip, parsnip, and carrot seed to Plymouth almost immediately. These were the 'potatoes' of the 1600s colonist — potatoes weren't common in New England yet.

Makes 12 servingsHands-on 30 minTotal 1¼ hrs

A Grand Sallet

A big English 'sallet' of greens, herbs, and radishes in oil and vinegar.

Needs a cook

Robert May's 1660 cookbook 'The Accomplisht Cook' describes Grand Sallets of mixed greens, herbs, and fruit, dressed with oil and vinegar.

Makes 12 servingsHands-on 25 minTotal 25 min

Pease Pottage

Split peas slow-cooked with ham hock, onion, and herbs. Thick and smoky.

Needs a cook

'Pease porridge hot, pease porridge cold…' Dried peas came over on the Mayflower and were grown in Plymouth. Everyday English food.

Makes 12 servingsHands-on 20 minTotal 2 hrs

Sauce of Stewed Cranberries

Fresh cranberries simmered with maple and orange until they burst. Not from a can.

Needs a cook

Josselyn (1672) describes the English boiling cranberries with sugar “for sauce to eat with their meat.” Native people used cranberries fresh, dried, and in pemmican.

Makes 12 servingsHands-on 15 minTotal 2 hrs (includes cooling)

Breads

Johnnycakes (Journey Cakes)

Simple cornmeal cakes fried crisp in butter.

The Host

The colonists learned cornbread from the Wampanoag, whose 'nokake' was parched corn ground fine. Johnnycakes are the plainest, oldest version — corn, salt, water, fat.

Makes 12 servingsHands-on 45 minTotal 1 hr (about 2 cakes per person)

Manchet Bread

Small round white loaves — the fine bread of the English table.

The Host

Manchet was the best-quality wheaten bread in 17th-century England: small, round, white loaves for the tables of those who could afford it.

Makes 12 servingsHands-on 30 minTotal 3½ hrs (mostly rising)

Sweets & the Banquet

Indian Pudding

Cornmeal, milk, and molasses baked low and slow with ginger and cinnamon.

Needs a cook

The colonists took English 'hasty pudding' and swapped wheat for Indian corn — hence the name. The original New England dessert, a century older than pumpkin pie.

Makes 12 servingsHands-on 25 minTotal 3 hrs

Baked Apples with Currants & Spice

Whole apples stuffed with raisins, butter, and spice, baked in cider.

Needs a cook

Apple seeds came over almost immediately, and Massachusetts Bay had orchards by the 1630s. Roasted apples with spice and dried fruit were a beloved English sweet.

Makes 12 servingsHands-on 25 minTotal 1¼ hrs

Cheese, Butter & Pickles Board

Hard cheeses, good butter, pickles, and dried fruit to end the meal.

Needs a cook

An English feast always ended with a 'banquet' course of cheese, fruits, and sweetmeats. Cheshire and Cheddar were the cheeses of the day.

Makes 12 servingsHands-on 20 minTotal 20 min

Drink

Hot Spiced Cider

Apple cider simmered with whole spices and orange.

The Host

Cider was the everyday drink of New England — orchards were planted as much for cider as for eating. Spiced and warmed, it was a feast-day drink.

Makes 12 servingsHands-on 10 minTotal 1 hr

Not on the 1650 Table

Lovingly, please leave these at home.